Voices of Inclusion
http://voicesofinclusion.com
Voices of Inclusion

When the Boss is Out

My husband hates it when new words find their way into the dictionary. Words like ginormous and microgreen. But I like new words. It gives me new ways to think about things.

Take the word 'executive'. It's not a new word and one that currently has some fairly negative connotations (such as in executive golden parachute, and executive jet...) but it is new for many parents, students and educators. It has not been very long that I could use the term "'executive function' and not think that it was what the CEO did.

According to the Encyclopedia of Mental Disorders, the term executive function "describes a set of cognitive abilities that control and regulate other abilities and behaviors. Executive functions are necessary for goal-directed behavior. They include the ability to initiate and stop actions, to monitor and change behavior as needed, and to plan future behavior when faced with novel tasks and situations. Executive functions allow us to anticipate outcomes and adapt to changing situations. The ability to form concepts and think abstractly are often considered components of executive function."

Well now that I look at that, it is what the CEO should be doing. Which makes it the obvious analogy for young people who have a deficit in their executive functioning.  This is the student is teachers love and hate. They can tell the student is bright, intellectually capable, and often verbally engaging but darn it, they just don't get their work done. I still hear teachers say things like, "If you just focused." or "if you just applied yourself" or 'if you just turned it your homework, you could get an A."

Does it occur to them that if the student could, he or she would?

People, like businesses, affected by executive functioning issues, look disorganized, disinterested, and unfocused. They don't plan well, prioritize well, or anticipate well. They often significantly overestimate or underestimate how long things might take. A mom I know is trying to help her son understand how long he is in the shower- he loses all sense of time and priority once he's in there. This same student, with the help of a skilled teacher, is realizing that when he sits in an class and hears what the assignment is, he thinks, " I can do that." But a day or a week later, he has no idea how to start the work. So he doesn't.

I am trying to find a way that we can have students struggling with executive functions problems, whether it's part of their AD/HD, autism or learning disability,  share what it's like to be in their head with teachers, administrators, parents, and other students. I got a glimpse of this myself.

I was talking to a good friend about my desire to find a way for these students voices to be heard and to develop strong strategies to help support them in the classroom and in life. I could barely explain it. I felt confused and overwhelmed with the ginormous task. I could not figure out how to start. I didn't know if I should go on-line, get a book, go to a doctor or talk to teachers. My friend suggested that I graphically organize my thoughts and ideas. And then I got it; This is what executive functioning problems feel like. I knew I was on to something but I sure couldn't make any sense of it.  Using visual structure to organize is a great strategy to organize projects.

It takes more than strategies to give our students the tools they need to succeed. First, they need to understand how their brain works. Then they need individualized approaches to organizing, planning and prioritize. They need to try things that don't work until they find what does work. They need to be guided to think is creative ways for solutions that are sustainable, meaningful and that work.

I plan to talk more specifically about these areas and include real-life examples. That is once I get myself graphically organized.


Heart Before Head

A teenage girl was asked why she thought that the pilot program she had just completed was important. The program was through Rachel Kessler's  Passage Works Institute. The goal was to bring the soul back into education. The teen's teacher said, "Help me figure out how to explain the value of this program. It's so complex."

The teen gave him a puzzled look, "It's easy. When you hold my heart, my brain can learn."

Passage Works describes their work as "Dedicated to transforming the culture of classrooms, schools and districts so that the inner life of students and teachers is safe, nurtured and welcomed. By “inner life” we refer to that essential aspect of human nature that yearns for deep connection, grapples with difficult questions about meaning, and seeks a sense of purpose and genuine self-expression."

While I encourage readers to check out their work and read more about the gateways to developing a rich inner life and how the Institute works in public and private schools, I think that there is a fundamental truth that is often overlooked by the special education system. That  truth is that  students need to feel that they they belong at school. They need to feel that it matters to others that they are in the room. They need to feel that they have something valuable to offer. They need to feel a connection to the people -adults and students. They need to feel, as the teenager above said so well, that their hearts are held.

At a recent middle school meeting for a young man with the label of SIED (Significant Identifiable Emotional Disability), his parents shared with the team that he comes home saying he is scared at school. The father had tears in his eyes as he shook his head, "We have to do something. My son does not feel safe at school. If he doesn't feel safe, he can't learn."

The team came up with a variety of strategies and I checked in a couple of weeks later. Things were much better. "What worked?" I asked. The team told me that the principal was going out during passing periods and standing near the boys' locker. He wasn't really doing anything, just standing by. The young man now felt that someone, in fact the head guy, had his back. He started smiling again. He started sharing again. He started learning again.

The team also looked for other ways to engage the student in meaningful ways to the school. He was feeling that no one really cared if he came to school or not. They put him back at the school store- a role he loved but due to schedule conflicts, had been cut. I was glad to see it corrected but I am concerned that this decision did not even acknowledge, much less support, that being part of the school store was the key to this boys connection to school.

Now, the heart is always part of the equation. I use it with my own kids. I ask it at IEP meetings. I talk to parents about it. I ask the question in some form or another, "Is your child's heart held at school?" Without it, their brain's won't work.


When Teachers Have Positive Behavior

The first day of school my 8th grader came home and said," The teachers must have gotten some training, Mom. They are all being nice."

My son has ADHD and struggles at times with staying engaged, controlling his impulses, and connecting to school work. Like many kids with ADHD though, he is very observant and sensitive.

At first I figured it was the honeymoon of the first day- everyone on their best behavior, all hoping for a good year. But then he started telling me more specifics, "Last year, my math teacher would have  'yelled' at me for not finishing my work," he explained. "This year, she told me it was OK because she knew I had done my best."

I knew something he didn't know but he could see. The teachers were receiving new training-the School-Wide Positive Behavior Support Program. The goal, as this site explains, http://www.pbis.org

In the past, school-wide discipline has focused mainly on reacting to specific student misbehavior by implementing punishment-based strategies including reprimands, loss of privileges, office referrals, suspensions, and expulsions. Research has shown that the implementation of punishment, especially when it is used inconsistently and in the absence of other positive strategies, is ineffective. Introducing, modeling, and reinforcing positive social behavior is an important of a student’s educational experience. Teaching behavioral expectations and rewarding students for following them is a much more positive approach than waiting for misbehavior to occur before responding. The purpose of school-wide PBS is to establish a climate in which appropriate behavior is the norm.

As my son sees it, that means the teachers are learning to model better behavior. They are trying to give students more positive comments. They are pausing before letting their own biases come out. They are recognizing that they play a big part in how students behave in their classrooms and in the school buildings.

And the payoff is already apparent. My son has first-hand experience with punishment-based strategies at this same school. He learned to shut-down, not engage, not raise his hand, and not like school. Already he can feel the difference and is completing all his assignments, developing respectful relationships with his teachers, and he has already accumulated over a dozen "getting busted for good behavior" slips. I haven't heard a negative statement yet.

He has changed because the adults have changed. Last year teachers verbally attacked him for not being the kind of student they preferred. They were (rightly) frustrated by his clear intelligence and obvious ability that he did not want to share with them.  He did change some and raised his grades so they got off his back. But he didn't care about them or about school. He was surviving. Now it looks like he just might thrive.


Oh, He's Like Hank

Sometimes it takes a book to explain a person.

Let me explain. My son was trying to figure out his classmates' challenges. He knew his friend struggled with academics but was also a smart kid. I tried to explain that while his friend was bright, he had trouble showing people what he knew through reading or writing. My son could see how hard he worked to write or to read aloud. It still didn't feel like true understanding of what it might be like to be his classmate. "It's kind of like Hank Zipzer," I said, "you know, from the books?"

The light went on. "Like Hank? Oh I get it," he said.

Hank Zipzer: The Mostly True Confessions of the World's Best Underachiever
is a series written by Henry Winkler (the Fonz) and Lin Oliver. Hank is a kid who lives with his parents, sister, and his dog Cheerio in New York. Hank is smart and creative. He has two best friends who get him, shares pickles with his grandfather, and has learning challenges. He has difficulty showing what he knows. Like my son's classmate, he doesn't like school because it asks him to act and respond in ways that are not within him. The books are also very funny as Hank tries to fit his round self inside the square holes that school and society expects of him.

I've always believed in the power of books to show us our own humanity. Reading a book about someone not like us, gives us insight into what it's like to live in that person's skin. It allows an intimacy that is hard to get in real life. It's safe. It's accessible. And it can be highly entertaining. The Hank series  work because they ring true- Henry Winkler also has learning challenges so he writes from the inside out.

My son read the Hank books because they are well-written, funny stories.  And because he did, he understands what it's like to be a kid who learns differently. He feels it.

Thanks Henry. Thanks Hank.




Riding Bareback

One of the ironies of parenting is that just as you think you know who your child is and what they can and can not do, they prove you wrong. I got this lesson yet again when Sabrina, my 9-year-old daughter with developmental delays, graduated from the basic therapeutic horseback riding center and started at a new barn.

The teacher was the same but the horses much younger and faster. Upon our arrival, the teacher L put my daughter and the horse, Shonie, in a pen to get to know each other. Now until this moment, Sabrina had been riding with a  teacher and a side-walker who had the horse on a lead rope. And the horses were very old and very slow. This was new.

Sabrina petted the horse and then L had Sabrina put on the halter and lead her around the pen by herself. Again the contrast of barely being allowed to hold the end of the rope while an adult held the main rope at last week's lesson was amazing.

Together they put on reins and a pad but no saddle or stirrups. Sabrina got on (mostly on her own) and started riding this sweet mare around a small arena. She shifted and slipped and steered. She rode this pony like she had been riding all her life.  No fear, no worries, she just took the reins and rode. She was in heaven. I was a bit in shock.

In that moment, I had to discard my beliefs about her riding a horse. This was the real thing-wild, big and powerful and in that moment I saw it in both Sabrina and her horse. The horse tried to do whatever Sabrina asked.  Sabrina tried to figure out how to ask her to do what she wanted.  

As I witnessed my daughter, I had to form a new picture of who she is and what she can do.  In that moment, I saw a girl who loves horses and is completely capable of riding them.  As she bounced on Shonie's back, she was not her disabilities; she was a girl learning to ride a horse.

The next week, she learned to put on a saddle and started trotting. She told us she wants to learn to jump and canter. And now I know she will. Sabrina is an equestrian.

Now it's my turn to learn how not to cringe when she falls off or put limits on her goals. Sabrina rides bareback, whether I can or not. This belongs to her.

Fiction or Fact: Lottery

I found Lottery by Patricia Wood sitting on the new fiction shelf at the library. I'm always looking for good novels that feature characters with disabilities- and this is the best one I have read in years.

The hero of this refreshing novel is a man named Perry L Crandall. He tells us the story of his life. He sets a tone from the first page when he tells readers the most important thing, “I am thirty-two years old and I am not retarded.  You have to have an IQ number less than 75 to be retarded. I read that in Reader’s Digest. I am not. Mine is 76.”

The next thing he wants you to know is that he won twelve million dollars in the Washington State Lottery. First-time novelist Wood has crafted a defining story. She has taken a character that at first does not seem to be someone we know. After all, how many of us really know people with cognitive disabilities? But she masterfully finds the commonality in this likable character. Perry loves, longs, and laughs. He does best with routine and predictability but he manages to navigate his way though his unusual life and circumstances by listening to his heart. His Grams, who dies early in the book, taught him many things, including how to save and spend, literally and figuratively. She tells him that’s “it’s very important to think of your future, because at some point it becomes your past.”

Her words of wisdom foreshadow the conflicts that come when she dies and when he wins the lottery. She knows he is suggestible (one of his words of the day) and they make a list of whom he can trust. His family is not on the list. But his friend Keith is and so is Gary, the owner of Holsted’s Marine Supply where Perry has worked since his grandfather taught him about boats. When his beloved Gram dies, his half-brothers sell the house they shared from under him and kick him out with $200. It is hard to read when you start to personalize through Perry what happens to adults with disabilities all over the country. Wood makes us uncomfortable but still wanting to discover what will happen next.

This could have been a bitter book, about how family and friends can be spiteful, prejudiced and horrid. But it’s not. Perry does not become like them. He maintains his wonderful sense of self throughout the book. He doesn’t want revenge or to keep all the money for himself. He wants to be with his friends, he wants to be in love, he wants to be part of the store’s success. He wants a good life and he has one.

It’s rare to see the main character be an adult with disabilities. It’s a fine line between making them someone we pity and someone who inspires us to be ourselves. It might challenge some readers to look at their own negative beliefs, name-calling, and other derogatory remarks towards people who may (or may not) be mentally retarded. Perry shows us that even our assumptions that all people with cognitive challenges are the same needs to be challenged. Perry is clearly a well-defined individual and deserves our full attention. As you can imagine, winning the lottery brings out the hunger in others for his money and he has to learn to manage this new role. His true friends, Keith, Gary and Cherry (the young woman he loves but who loves Keith) help him as they expand their own perspectives about Perry. For instance, without his money, would Gary consider having someone like Perry become an active business partner?

You’ll have to read Lottery to find out what choices Perry makes and just what the L. in his name stands for. It’s worth the time.

Is it Fun, Meaningful, and Sustainable?

This is the question I ask parents and professionals I work with, groups I facilitate, programs I create, and with my own family. Living and working with people of all kinds of ages, abilities, temperaments and roles, requires organization, respect, clear agreements and boundaries, and defined goals. By using these three qualites as the foundation for successful collaboration, we can make desciosn that support the health, growth, and outcome for people and for the systems we work within. Today, I'll talk about the three qualities.  

Is it fun? One thing I’ve learned from living and working with so many people who have ADHD, is that many of them like to keep things lively. It’s what gets my teenaged son into trouble at school and at home. While I am trying to teach him to find acceptable ways to make class time more interesting, he does bring a certain spark to the room.  As an adult, fun means being present in a positive, enthusiastic way. At times, it could mean silly, or goofy, or playful. But it’s much deeper than that. Ask if whatever you are doing is fun by asking;
  • Is it engaging?
  • Does it make you feel alive?
  • Are your senses heightened?
  •  Do you lose track of time and worry?

Then it’s fun.

Is it meaningful? This is the heart of what is important.. Everyone, whatever their abilities, has a fundamental need to matter. Until we have a sense of belonging, we have diffulty learning and colloaborating. If we can’t learn or work together, then we feel badly about ourselves. If we feel badly about ourselves, we don’t feel worthy as people and a negative cycle is created. Belonging gives us a place to feel meaningful. When we belong, we are contributing to the group. Our involvement matters. We matter.

Is it sustainable? In order to keep doing the work it takes to be present and have fun, to belong and be meaningful, our efforts have to be sustainable. Great ideas are important but without sustainable implementation, it won’t work. It’s sort of like New Years’ Resolutions, if we try to do too much, such as start a new diet and start exercising, we are usually asking for too much and can’t sustain the effort it takes to change. Start with what is sustainable.

When I was the PTA president at my kids’ school, I used these three themes to direct all my decisions. I wanted our monthly meetings to be worth attending. So I set up a structure to run the meetings in that always included time for every voice to be heard (meaningful), time to pause and be present often in a whimsical way (fun) and each meeting followed the same basic format (sustainable). The school still uses that structure.

I also ask these questions when I talk to parents about their child’s school experience.  I encourage them to reframe their IEP goals and meetings around the question of if what we are doing/offering engagement, connection and continuity?
  • Does the student feel they belong?
  • Do they engage in meaningful activities throughout their day?
  • Is fun defined by being pulled out of class for a special ed field trip or by doing experiments in science lab?
  • Can the student sustain the effort to participare and learn?
  • Can the adults working with the student sustain the effort to provide meaningful participation and engaging learning?
  • Are the goals and objectives consistent with a long-term vision of community involvment?
  • Do those involved feel heard, valued, and respected?

How do you ensure your team's efforts are fun, meaningful, and sustainable?

Roots of Conflict

Tracy’s entry on how to manage conflict resolution struck a note with me. In my role as a parent liaison, I’ve noticed a core issue at the heart of every conflict. The core issue is that parents want the educational team to see their child the way they do. They don’t think the team sees their child’s gifts, strengths, and potential in the way they do. And they are right. As parents, taking care of our kids is not a job, it’s our lives. We know what they look like when they sleep, we know what their first words were, how they brush their teeth and every detail of their lives. No one understands our kids like we do.

It happens on the other side of the table as well. Teachers and specialists working with our kids often feel that the parents don’t see all that they are doing on behalf of the student. Or how much progress she or he has made. They feel unseen too. Addressing this gap requires a face-to-face meeting but meetings aren’t usually called just to help the IEP team “see’ the child. We usually have to have some kind of reason and that’s when the focus goes on the IEP and what the team is or isn’t doing to implement it. The downside of this as the reason to meet means that there is a focus on the negative. It puts people in the defensive position even before the meeting starts. One way to help prevent this is to share a parent report before the meeting. (see previous blog)

In this way, the IEP becomes a tool. I’ve noticed that when there is agreement and openness about who a student is, what the goals and expected outcomes are, that the IEP itself becomes secondary. It’s just the details. When a team really gets a child, they usually want to support that child and they are motivated to meet their needs, however they are written in the IEP. So to me, the most important thing a team can do is make sure that every member has the opportunity to share what they know about the student and what they see as the student’s strengths, gifts and contributions. Everyone needs to be heard, even if their perspective is different from the parents.

Another source of conflict is the discrepancy between what a team is doing and what they could be doing. Parents call me and complain that the team isn’t doing this or that. They might say that the team isn’t doing things right. And they may be right. But that doesn’t mean that the team isn’t doing their jobs. Parents want the best for their child even when they don’t really now what best is. Schools are bound to provide access to the curriculum but no where in the law does it say they have to do what is best. How can we accept that? No wonder parents feel that school teams have low expectations. And why teams feel that parents expect too much from them. When people are stuck here, it’s even harder to see the child.

How do you create a meaningful meeting?
 1. Work with the facilitator of the meeting to ensure there is time for everyone to talk, starting with the parents. Share what you expect school to be like for your child and what the most important parts are to you.
 2. Look for something positive to say about the professionals working with your child. Share it with the person.
 3. Listen without comment or interruption when the professionals have their turn. Stay focused on the child.

The more we all practice listening to everyone a the table ,including listening to what’s hard or challenging, the more likely we can find common ground in serving the needs of our children.

Conflict: What Are We Missing? by Tracy Gershwin Mueller, Ph.D.

" The most intense conflicts, if overcome, leave behind a sense of security and calm that is not easily disturbed. It is just these intense conflicts and their conflagration, which are needed to produce valuable and lasting results."
- from Carl Jung, Swiss Psychiatrist

The Problem
Perhaps one of the most overlooked expenses in the field of special education is litigation. The numbers of due process hearings that are taking place across the United States are continuing to increase on an annual basis. In fact, it was estimated that over 14,000 due process hearings would take place during the 2006-2007 academic year. These statistics are just now being analyzed and could be as much or more than the predicted numbers. The costs accrued through a hearing could be as much as $50,000 per hearing, with some cases that reach Federal appeals court costing as much as $60,000 to $100,000. School districts across the U.S. report spending over $90 million a year in conflict resolution. This is a great cost considering all of the drastic budget cuts education is continuing to experience through general and special education.

What do these numbers mean for us? Simply put, we are spending more money to have people resolve our own conflict then to just address it ourselves. External activities, funds, and energy are being used unnecessarily. The reality is that the majority of the conflict can and should be addressed internally. After all, how can a district and families learn to resolve disputed issues if they are not given the opportunity themselves?

The irony here is that in the field of special education we promote the concept of self-regulation and self-management. We educate our students with the goal that they can work through their social, academic, and behavioral needs internally, rather than externally. Yet when it comes to the adults who work with these students it is far more accessible and accepted to become so entwined within a conflict that we go straight to a hearing and ask a hearing officer to resolve the issue. The end result is simple. Districts and parents are forced to experience the emotional rollercoaster of a hearing, high legal fees, and a relationship that will most likely be disjointed for good. One issue that most people do not consider at this conjuncture is the relationship between those families and districts that will still be required until the child turns twenty-one years of age. The next questions left before the team is, "What happens if another issue of disagreement arises?" If this is the case, the team has clearly not learned or grown through the experience of working through conflict together. Thus hearing number two is not too far off the horizon.

One important issue to note is that due process hearings should not be viewed as meaningless and inappropriate. On the contrary, due process provisions were written into the law to provide parents with some legal options should their child's Free and Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) be compromised. There is no argument that due process should remain an option for families and, when appropriate, can be very beneficial to the educational team. The issue that should be considered is, "When is a due process hearing appropriate?" Further, "Are we overly using this legal right when in reality conflict could otherwise be resolved between parties?"

There is no question that conflict is uncomfortable. Depending on our own backgrounds, experiences, beliefs, and practices we all address conflict with our own styles. Many people alike this response as one where it is either "fight or flight." Thus when an option such as due process is available, there is a simple "out" for educational teams to exercise. This concern is heightened by the amount of revenue we are spending on our responses to conflict.

Potential Solution
As a teacher educator who works in a highly respected university that prepares students to become special educators, this issue is magnified when I look at the status of most special education licensure programs across the U.S. With the IDEA (2004) and No Child Left Behind (2001) mandates, universities are pressured to prepare highly qualified teachers. Teacher educators are also well aware of the mass shortage of special educators across the county. The final compounding variable is the pressure to prepare and graduate special educators at an increasing rate. The result of these two collisions is universities pressured to gain student enrollment that can complete a program with a minimum number of credits at a quick rate so that they can serve our much-neglected field.

The shortened programs combined with highly qualified educators results in classes that are focused on standards with regard to teacher pedagogy, and very little focus on teacher collaboration, specifically alternative dispute resolution strategies. Thus, teachers are not being prepared to deal with conflict. The programs focus more on the students they teach with little focus on all of the educational members they are required to work with.

One clear solution to this issue is to first acknowledge that conflict is inevitable and needs to be addressed. Similar to the proactive behavior management techniques we promote through the Positive Behavior Support (PBS) movement, we need to prepare our educators for conflict. Teachers can learn strategies for communicating effectively, problem solving, and finding mutual solutions. Models from other disciplines, such as the medical practice and business industries should be considered and applied to our own system so that we can create options to hearings rather than only mediation or litigation. The end result will be well prepared educators who can collaborate and problem solve with families. Due process should and will still be available, when appropriate.

For more information on Conflict and appropriate dispute resolution, please visit the CADRE website

Parent Tip #1 Preparing for an IEP

Tracy recently wrote about parents who are not actively involved in their child’s’ IEP. In my work as a parent liaison, I have a bagful of tips I offer to parents to be more prepared to participate in their child’s IEP. This is the first tip in series I will post on this blog.

Tip #1:
Write a 'parent report'
All the other professionals will write a report. Your voice should be included in your child’s file. I believe that every parent should present their report just like all the other professionals do and take time to do a thorough, meaningful assessment of their child through their own eyes. I have found that the most effective presentation is one page. Put your child’s name and birthday on the top along with the parent’s names and the date. Open with a short paragraph giving an overall picture of your child. Then make a bulleted list in four categories - 1) Strengths, 2) Interests, 3) Needs, and 4) Friendships.

Even though I have worked with the same team for several years, I always provide a parent report at every annual or triennial IEP meeting. My daughter changes and I want the adults working with her to remember that and use my information to adjust their teaching strategies to support her strengths. They may know she likes to sing but I can tell them that she is learning the songs from Annie and learning about orphans and adoption. When they do a social study unit on families, she has awareness of different kinds of families.

When we met for Sabrina’s triennial in second grade, her assessments showed she was over a year behind academically. We weren’t surprised but it did make us consider every accommodation available to help support her. I used my parent report to remind them of her strengths and interests. I wanted to encourage them to use some new accommodations that drew from her interests to help learn to read and write.

This is what her report looked like. To protect other's privacy, some areas have been omitted.

Parent Report, 2006

Sabrina is a good friend, affectionate daughter, caring sister, and engaged learner. She is as eager to learn to read as she is to plan an American Girl sleepover with her best friends. She has a natural social grace and is working on standing up for herself. Every day she wakes up cheerful, cares for her guinea pig, sings, reads, draws, and loves her family and friends.

Strengths:
Social connections to peers
Loyal to friends
Low anxiety
Comfortable with physical contact and games
Singing and music
Enthusiastic learner
Willing to try, even when it's difficult
Transitions easily
Follows classroom routines and rules

Interests:
American Girls
Ballet
Horse-back riding
Sleepovers
Parties
Playdates
Singing
Visiting family in California
Traveling

Needs
Communication strategies for all mediums -  verbal, reading, writing
Generalizing concepts across mediums and environments
More time to process when response is required
Options for helping others understand her speech
Increase expectations from staff and self
Opportunities to be a leader
Talk to her about strategies, tools, and her supports
Needs lots of repitition to grasp concepts, master skills,or anticipate evetns
Self-advocacy